Don't forget to share this post!

Midwest Family Mutual: The Hidden Gem of Trucking Insurance You’ve Probably Never Heard Of

If you’ve been in the trucking industry for any length of time, you’ve probably heard the same names over and over again: Progressive, Great West, Sentry, Northland, Canal… the list goes on.
But what if I told you there’s a smaller, Midwest-based insurance company quietly writing some of the best trucking policies in the country — with competitive rates, full coverage options, and unmatched stability?

Let’s talk about Midwest Family Mutual — who they are, what they offer, and why most truckers (and even agents) don’t know much about them.

Why You’ve Probably Never Heard of Midwest Family Mutual

The first thing to know is that Midwest Family Mutual isn’t like the big national carriers.
They’re a mutual insurance company, which means they’re owned by their policyholders — not shareholders. In other words, their goal isn’t to maximize profit; it’s to build long-term relationships with good risks and pay claims fairly.

That alone sets them apart in today’s market. Mutuals tend to be smaller and more selective, and Midwest Family Mutual fits that mold perfectly. They only work with a limited number of agencies, and only in the Midwest region. So unless your agent is one of their appointed partners (and most aren’t), you’d never even know they existed.

They’re also a bit old-school in their process. Unlike Progressive or Geico, you can’t just call and get a rate over the phone. Instead, you have to fill out detailed forms, provide IFTAs and loss runs, and wait a couple of business days for underwriting to review it.

That extra step turns a lot of agents away — but it’s also what helps keep their book of business clean and their rates competitive.

At Nelson Insurance Agency, we’ve been appointed with Midwest Family Mutual for about three years. Initially, we didn’t use them much because their quoting process was slower than what we were used to. However, after sitting down with their reps and seeing the results firsthand, we realized we’d been sitting on one of the best trucking insurance markets in the Midwest.

Who’s a Good Fit for Midwest Family Mutual

Midwest Family Mutual is not for everyone. They’re not interested in brand-new startups or high-risk commodities. Instead, they want professional, established carriers with clean records and sound operations.

Here’s their sweet spot:

  • 3+ years in business

  • Experienced drivers (no new or unqualified drivers)

  • Primary operation radius of 750 miles or less

  • Based or primarily operating in the Midwest (think: Ohio to the Dakotas, down through Missouri, Kansas, and into Arizona/Nevada)

Preferred commodities:

  • Livestock (they love livestock haulers)

  • Grain and agricultural products

  • Reefer

  • Flatbed

  • Dry van

  • Hopper bottom

They typically won’t write:

  • Hazmat haulers

  • Oversized or heavy equipment loads

  • Dirt, sand, and gravel operations

  • 100% over-the-road carriers (especially long-haul coast-to-coast)

  • Fleets based in tough insurance states like California, Florida, Texas, or New York

If your trucking company mainly runs the Midwest, hauls ag commodities, and has experienced drivers, you’re exactly who Midwest Family Mutual wants to insure.

What Midwest Family Mutual Offers That Most Don’t

Here’s where things get interesting. Midwest Family Mutual doesn’t just write competitive rates — they offer coverage options that most truckers don’t realize even exist.

1. Competitive Pricing That Holds Up Against the Big Names

We’ve seen them consistently beat Progressive, Sentry, and even Great West for the right risk.

In one case, we had a client move from Great West to Midwest Family Mutual and save over $9,000 per year with equal or better coverage.

Because they’re a mutual, their rate stability is strong — they don’t spike premiums every renewal cycle just because of market trends. Their philosophy is simple: “We want to write the best operators and keep them for life.”

2. All-in-One Coverage Packages

Midwest Family Mutual can bundle your auto liability, physical damage, cargo, general liability, pollution, and umbrella coverage — all under one roof.
This approach keeps your claims handling smoother and avoids the finger-pointing you sometimes see when multiple carriers are involved.

3. Coverage Perks You Don’t See Everywhere Else

Here are a few things they offer that many carriers don’t:

  • Collision between your own vehicles (a big one — most carriers exclude this)

  • Pollution liability built into the policy

  • Coverage for in-cab electronics, personal property, and tools

  • Loan/lease gap coverage

  • Rental reimbursement after a covered loss

  • Combined deductibles, which can reduce your out-of-pocket costs if multiple coverages are triggered in one event

These are small details, yet they make a big difference when you have a claim.

4. Excellent Claims Experience

Mutual companies tend to handle claims differently — they’re not pressured by shareholders to minimize payouts.

With Midwest Family Mutual, claims get handled fairly, and they’re known for being easy to work with. You’re not going to get lost in a massive call center or bounced around departments. Instead, you’ll receive personal service from real people who understand trucking.

Why Most Agents Don’t Offer Midwest Family Mutual

The truth? It’s not because they don’t like the company — it’s because they don’t have access or don’t want to deal with the manual quoting process.

Midwest Family Mutual requires:

  • IFTA summaries

  • Loss runs

  • A completed trucking questionnaire

  • Driver and equipment schedules

That’s a bit more effort than clicking “submit” on an online portal. However, for trucking companies who qualify, the savings and coverage differences are worth every minute of extra paperwork.

As an agency, we’re working directly with Midwest Family Mutual to streamline the quoting process so we can get these quotes back faster and make them more accessible to truckers across our 40 licensed states.

How to Get a Quote

To get a quote with Midwest Family Mutual, you’ll need to work with an appointed agency — and there aren’t many.

At Nelson Insurance Agency, we’re proud to be one of the few agencies in the Midwest with direct access to them. We’ll walk you through the process step by step and make sure everything is submitted cleanly so you get the most accurate rate possible.

Here’s what you’ll need to have ready:

  • IFTAs (last four quarters)

  • Loss runs (past 3–5 years)

  • Driver list and experience history

  • Equipment list with VINs and values

  • Description of your commodities and operations

Once we have that, Midwest Family Mutual can typically turn around a quote in a few business days.

Final Thoughts: Why This Carrier Deserves More Attention

I talk to truckers every day who tell me things like,

“There are only two companies that’ll take me in my state.”

That’s just not true anymore. The problem isn’t always that options don’t exist — it’s that many agents don’t have access to the right markets.

Midwest Family Mutual is one of those hidden gems. They’ve been around since 1891, they’re A-rated, and they’re built for professional, Midwest-based carriers who take pride in running a clean operation.

So if you’re hauling grain, livestock, or other agricultural commodities and haven’t had your policy reviewed recently, this is one carrier that deserves a serious look.

Next Step

We are here to serve truckers through commercial trucking insurance, risk management, and industry support. Want to learn more or work with us? Request a quote or call.

Related Articles