---

What Captive Insurance Actually Is

A captive is a private insurance company that you (or a group you’re part of) own.

Instead of sending premium to a traditional carrier:

• You pay into your own insurance structure
• You fund your own predictable losses
• You keep the profit when losses are low

For trucking companies, captives typically cover:

• Commercial auto liability
• Physical damage
• Motor truck cargo
• Workers’ compensation

Simple idea:
If you run a safer operation, you should keep the financial upside—not the insurance company.

---

The 3 Main Types of Captives

1. Single Parent Captive (Build Your Own)

• One company owns the captive
• Full control over pricing, claims, and structure
• Highest flexibility—and responsibility

Best for:

• Large fleets
• ~$1.5M+ in annual premium

---

2. Group Captive (Most Common)

• Multiple trucking companies pool risk
• Each member’s pricing is based mostly on their own losses
• Shared accountability across the group

Best for:

• Mid-sized fleets
• ~$500K+ in premium

Important: Good captives are selective—bad operators don’t get in.

---

3. Rent-a-Captive (Cell Captive)

• “Plug into” an existing captive
• Lower startup costs
• Separate financial results within the structure

Best for:

• Fleets testing the waters
• ~$250K+ in premium

---

How the Money Actually Works

A Fund (Your Money)

• Pays smaller, frequent claims
• If losses are low → you get money back

B Fund (Shared Layer)

• Covers larger claims
• Shared across the group

Reinsurance (Catastrophic Protection)

• Covers extreme losses
• Caps your total risk

👉 Translation:
You insure what you can predict, and only buy insurance for what you can’t.

---

Why Trucking Companies Are Switching

1. You Keep the Profit

In traditional insurance:

• Carrier collects premium
• Carrier keeps leftover profit

In a captive:

• You keep unused loss funds
• You earn investment income on reserves

---

2. You’re Priced on YOUR Performance

Instead of industry averages:

• Your 5-year loss history drives pricing
• Safe fleets stop subsidizing risky ones

---

3. Safety Has a Direct ROI

Every avoided claim = money back to you

That makes investments like:

• Dashcams
• Driver training
• Telematics
• Maintenance programs

…financially measurable—not just “nice to have.”

---

4. More Predictable Costs

No more market-driven swings every renewal

• Costs tied to your performance
• Easier long-term budgeting

---

The Trade-Offs (This Matters)

Captives are powerful—but not easy.

You Take on More Risk

• Bad claims year = real financial impact
• You need capital reserves

---

You Need Strong Operations

• Claims management matters
• Safety culture must already exist

---

There Are Upfront Costs

• Setup, legal, admin
• Savings come over time—not immediately

---

Group Captives = Shared Accountability

• Weak members can hurt results
• Strong programs remove poor performers

---

Is Your Fleet a Good Fit?

A captive usually makes sense if:

• You spend $250K+ annually on insurance
• You have consistent, strong loss history
• You run a serious safety program
• You can handle higher retention risk
• You’re thinking long-term (5–10 years)

👉 If you’re just shopping for the cheapest quote this year—this isn’t the right move.
👉 If you want to control your total cost of risk—this is where it gets interesting.

---

The Bottom Line

The traditional insurance model is hitting its limits for trucking.

Captives offer something fundamentally different:

• Keep the profit from running a safe fleet
• Get priced on your own performance
• Turn safety into a financial advantage

It’s more responsibility—but also more control.