Don't forget to share this post!

10 Best “Unknown” Trucking Insurance Companies Worth Considering

If you’re a fleet owner or owner-operator searching for the best unknown trucking insurance companies, you’ve probably realized that the big names — Progressive, Berkshire Hathaway, Great West, and Travelers — dominate most conversations. But outside of those giants, there’s an entire world of underrated trucking insurance companies offering innovative pricing, stronger safety tools, and flexible underwriting specifically built for trucking.

These lesser-known trucking insurers often deliver:

  • Real-world data-driven underwriting

  • Transparent, accurate pricing

  • Safety technology that actually reduces claims

  • Programs traditional insurance companies simply don’t offer

For many carriers, these companies end up being a better fit — especially if you want competitive premiums and a carrier that truly understands trucking.

Below are the 10 best “unknown” trucking insurance companies worth considering — along with details on why each one stands out.

(Helpful outbound links are included for sources such as FMCSA (https://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/) and Truckload Carriers Association (https://www.truckload.org/) to strengthen SEO.)

1. Nirvana Insurance — Best Unknown Trucking Insurance Company for Telematics Pricing

Why it’s unique:

  • Rates driven by real-time telematics

  • More accurate underwriting from continuous driving data

  • Pricing rewards safer fleets

  • Faster claims handling than traditional insurers

Best for:
Fleets and owner-operators who want insurance based on how they actually drive, not just historical loss runs.

2. HDVI (High Definition Vehicle Insurance)

Why it’s unique:

  • Uses ELD, dashcam, and telematics data to score driver safety

  • Pay-per-mile, performance-adjusted pricing

  • Safety coaching tools included

  • Faster claims support

Best for:
Fleets working to improve BASIC scores or reduce preventable accidents.

3. Ten Four Insurance

Why it’s unique:

  • Staffed by former transportation professionals

  • Extremely competitive pricing for newer fleets

  • Quick quoting and responsive underwriting

  • Flexible appetite for various trucking operations

Best for:
Truckers wanting a carrier that understands transportation and actually answers the phone.

4. OpenEyes Insurance

Why it’s unique:

  • AI-powered dashcam system included

  • Behavioral telematics tracks distracted driving, braking, distance, and more

  • Focuses on preventing accidents, not just paying claims

  • Designed for fleets of 5–250+ trucks

Best for:
Fleets wanting built-in safety technology with their insurance program.

5. Lancer Insurance

Why it’s unique:

  • Decades-long reputation in trucking and passenger transport

  • Appetite for harder-to-place operations

  • Highly experienced underwriters

  • Strong, specialized claims team

Best for:
Truckers with complex or unique operations needing underwriting expertise.

6. Acuity Insurance

Why it’s unique:

  • Excellent trucking coverages

  • Very competitive for local + regional fleets

  • One of the best claims teams in the Midwest

  • Known for stable long-term pricing

Best for:
Established fleets wanting reliability and strong service instead of bottom-dollar rates.

7. Auto-Owners Insurance

Why it’s unique:

  • A++ AM Best — extremely strong financially

  • Surprisingly competitive for local/regional trucking

  • Consistent underwriting

  • Underrated and often overlooked

Best for:
Local and regional carriers wanting dependable long-term partnerships.

8. Midwest Family Mutual

Why it’s unique:

  • Ideal for fleets in Midwest and Western states

  • Stable pricing that doesn’t swing with the market

  • Excellent claims handling

  • Known for strong livestock cargo coverage

Best for:
Small fleets wanting stability and fair pricing.

9. National Interstate Insurance

Why it’s unique:

  • One of the strongest specialty trucking insurers in the nation

  • Excellent captive program structures

  • Appetite includes hazmat, high-severity cargo, and specialty freight

  • Top-tier risk management

Best for:
Large or high-exposure fleets needing more advanced insurance solutions.

10. DMC Insurance — A Top Unknown Trucking Insurance Carrier for Large Fleets

Why it’s unique:

  • Minimum of 35 trucks required

  • Highly customizable program

  • Multiple ways to lower the total cost of risk

  • Financial backing from Crum & Forster

  • Designed for companies wanting more control and flexibility

Best for:
Growing or established fleets ready to transition into a more sophisticated insurance model.

Final Thoughts on Choosing the Best Unknown Trucking Insurance Companies

Choosing the right trucking insurance company isn’t just about finding the lowest premium. The best trucking carriers help you:

  • Lower your total cost of risk

  • Improve driver behavior

  • Reduce accidents

  • Improve safety scores

  • Build a more resilient business

Your insurance carrier should be a partner, not just an expense.

These best unknown trucking insurance companies provide options that many fleets overlook — but often deliver the strongest results.

And in trucking, the right carrier isn’t the cheapest one — it’s the one that keeps you profitable and protected.

Next Step

We are here to serve truckers through commercial trucking insurance, risk management, and industry support. Want to learn more or work with us? Request a quote or call.

Related Articles